The Ultimate Key West Dining Guide: 10 Must-Try Restaurants
Key West is a food lover’s paradise with a mix of fresh seafood, Cuban-inspired flavors, and one-of-a-kind island dishes. From casual beachside spots to elegant fine dining, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite, a romantic dinner, or a unique local experience, here are ten must-try restaurants in Key West to make your culinary tour unforgettable.
Blue Heaven: Iconic Key West Dining- Blue Heaven is a legendary Key West eatery known for its laid-back, tropical atmosphere and delicious food. Located in a charming outdoor space, this restaurant serves up dishes that celebrate Caribbean flavors with Key West flair. Their lobster benedict and Key Lime pie are famous, making this a perfect spot for brunch or a relaxed dinner under the stars.
Louie’s Backyard: Oceanfront Elegance- For an upscale dining experience with breathtaking ocean views, Louie’s Backyard is the place to be. This historic restaurant offers gourmet dishes featuring locally sourced seafood and fresh ingredients. Signature dishes like the conch chowder and pan-seared snapper showcase the best of Key West’s coastal cuisine. Reservations are recommended for this elegant spot, especially if you want a seat on the oceanfront deck.
El Siboney: Authentic Cuban Flavor- El Siboney is a beloved Cuban restaurant that brings authentic Latin flavors to Key West. Known for its hearty portions and affordable prices, El Siboney serves up traditional Cuban favorites like ropa vieja, picadillo, and their famous Cuban sandwich. This family-friendly spot offers a taste of Key West’s rich Cuban heritage in a casual, welcoming atmosphere.
A&B Lobster House: Seafood Lovers’ Dream- For seafood enthusiasts, A&B Lobster House is a must-visit. Located on the waterfront, this restaurant has been serving fresh lobster, oysters, and other seafood delights since 1947. Enjoy classic dishes like lobster thermidor and seafood pasta in an elegant setting with views of the marina. Their rooftop bar, Alonzo’s Oyster Bar, is also worth a visit for a more casual seafood experience.
Santiago’s Bodega: Tapas and Small Plates- Santiago’s Bodega is a popular spot for those looking to sample a variety of flavors. This cozy restaurant specializes in tapas, offering a diverse menu of small plates perfect for sharing. Favorites include the beef tenderloin, lamb patties, and stuffed dates. With its warm ambiance and inventive dishes, Santiago’s Bodega is an excellent choice for a memorable dining experience.
Hogfish Bar & Grill: Local Favorite on Stock Island- Just a short drive from Key West on Stock Island, Hogfish Bar & Grill is a hidden gem frequented by locals. Known for its signature hogfish sandwich, this laid-back seafood shack serves fresh, no-frills fare with an unbeatable waterfront view. Their fish tacos and conch fritters are also crowd-pleasers, making Hogfish a great spot for a casual meal with authentic island vibes.
Cafe Marquesa: Fine Dining with Flair- Cafe Marquesa offers an intimate fine dining experience right in the heart of Old Town. The menu focuses on contemporary American cuisine with an island twist, and dishes change seasonally to showcase fresh, local ingredients. Try the pan-roasted grouper or filet mignon for a taste of Key West’s high-end culinary scene. The elegant setting and top-notch service make this spot ideal for a romantic night out.
Garbo’s Grill: Gourmet Food Truck Experience- For a more casual yet delicious experience, head to Garbo’s Grill. This food truck has earned a cult following for its unique dishes like the shrimp taco with mango salsa and the Umami burger. The casual outdoor seating and friendly vibes make it a fun place to grab a quick, mouthwatering meal. Don’t be surprised if you have to wait – it’s a local favorite for a reason.
Pepe’s Cafe: A Key West Classic- Pepe’s Cafe is one of the oldest restaurants in Key West, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner since 1909. This charming spot is known for its hearty breakfasts and homestyle meals with a local twist. Their famous steak and eggs and fresh-squeezed orange juice mimosas make Pepe’s a great choice to start your day. The cafe’s rustic decor and historic charm add to its nostalgic appeal.
Latitudes: Dining on Sunset Key- For a truly unforgettable dining experience, take a short ferry ride to Sunset Key to dine at Latitudes. This luxurious restaurant offers open-air dining with stunning views of the ocean and breathtaking sunsets. The menu features upscale seafood and island-inspired dishes, like lobster mac & cheese and mahi-mahi. Be sure to reserve in advance, as this spot is highly sought after for special occasions.
From fine dining to food trucks, Key West’s culinary scene has something for every taste. Each of these restaurants offers a unique way to experience the island’s flavors, whether you’re craving fresh seafood, Cuban classics, or inventive tapas. If you’re planning your Key West food adventure, make sure to include these must-try spots on your list, and don’t forget to check out our downloadable Key West guide for more insider tips on where to eat, stay, and explore!
